The Directorate of Communications held the panel on “Truth in the Shadow of Disinformation: Israel and Gaza.”
The panel, held at the Presidency’s Directorate of Communications, was moderated by Deniz Demir, Coordinator of the Centre for Combating Disinformation at the Directorate.
Speaking at the panel, Demir pointed out that an information war had been waged since the first day of Israel’s attacks on Gaza, saying, “Disinformation is being used overtly as a weapon in this information war.”
Demir also noted that digital platforms played a prominent role in this process, explaining why the panel was organised under the title “The Two Faces of Israel: Massacre and Disinformation”.
“Israel has massacred 30,000 of our children”
Speaking at the panel, Aslan Değirmenci, Digital Media Coordinator at the Directorate of Communications, offered condolences on behalf of the Turkish nation to Palestinian journalist Huda Fadel Naim, who had lost members of her family as martyrs, and to the families and loved ones of press members killed in Gaza.
Stating that Israel had inflicted suffering not only through massacres and genocide but also through disinformation, Değirmenci explained that Israel had weaponised three significant lies in Gaza.
As the first example, Değirmenci cited the claim made by an Israeli television channel that “40 children had been beheaded by Hamas”, recalling that the claim had been refuted in a statement issued by the Centre for Combating Disinformation.
Değirmenci said, “While Hamas has not harmed a single child, Israel has massacred 30,000 of our children.”
Değirmenci also stated that the first response to another Israeli claim, which alleged that “Hamas terrorists were hiding in tunnels beneath hospitals in Gaza”, had come from Türkiye. He recalled that those who had set up camp at Al-Shifa Hospital were residents of Gaza, not Hamas members.
Noting that the Israeli media had subsequently been forced to retract their reports, Değirmenci said that, following these lies, Israel had killed 1,700 healthcare workers and 283 journalists during its three-year campaign of oppression.
“Türkiye countered this black propaganda through silence”
Stating that the work of the Centre for Combating Disinformation was not directed solely at Türkiye, Değirmenci said, “We have ensured the removal of many disinformation-laden reports published in Israeli and Western media. At the same time, we ensured that world-renowned newspapers apologised to Türkiye and even to the people of Gaza.”
Claiming that Israel had also employed ‘dirty election tactics’, Değirmenci recalled that Israeli officials – foremost among them Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister of the interim government – had consistently targeted President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan at campaign events. Değirmenci stated that this was an attempt to bring the electoral process under political control.
Stating that Türkiye and President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan countered this “black propaganda” through silence, Değirmenci said, “Some groups among us who describe themselves as opposition figures thought that Türkiye had taken a step back. No, this is our dignified stance.”
"The story does not end once the news is out; in fact, that is when it truly begins”
Journalist Huda Fadel Naim said that she began working as a journalist at the age of 18 and served at Al-Shifa Hospital during Israel’s attacks on Gaza in 2009.
Referring to news reports that give death tolls, Naim said, “The report says, ‘Four people died,’ but each of them has a story. They have a mother, a father, a loved one, and a child. The story does not end once the news is out; in fact, that is when it truly begins.”
Naim recounted that her father, who worked in an operating theatre at a hospital, had said of her 19-year-old brother Enes, who drove an ambulance in Gaza, “An ambulance is one of the safest places. Nothing will happen either in a hospital or an ambulance,” adding that they heard on the radio the news of the attack on the ambulance in which Enes was martyred.
Naim said that, even after 18 years, recounting the events still felt as vivid as if they had occurred yesterday, adding, “My mother is still crying. One day changed our lives; life never returned to the way it was.”
Pointing out that the number of people who have lost their lives in Gaza has approached 80,000, Naim said, “We are not numbers; we are human beings. Every number has a story, a family, a loved one, and a child,” Naim said.
Huda Fadel Naim said that Israel described her brother Enes as a mujahid fighting for Palestine and saw no issue with his death; her family filed a lawsuit against this claim but lost the case.
“Journalists in Gaza were portrayed as terrorists, and hospitals and UN schools were depicted as terrorist havens”
Yaser Emre, Anadolu Agency’s Global News Group Director, also highlighted three prominent disinformation tactics at the panel: removing witnesses, discrediting them, and using financial resources to spread misleading narratives.
Recalling that journalists in Gaza were portrayed as terrorists and hospitals and United Nations schools as havens of terrorism, Emre stated that bombardments and massacres followed.
Emphasising that combating disinformation is much more important for younger generations, Emre recalled that, under an agreement between Israel and Google, a propaganda film claiming that there was no hunger or famine in Gaza was distributed.
Emre said that reports published by independent UN bodies during the same period officially declared a famine in Gaza, while Israel disseminated its narrative to the entire world through a 45-million-dollar agreement.
Stating that such propaganda would have no validity in Türkiye and that everyone was united in a collective conscience against Israel, Emre underlined that the situation was different in global public opinion and that combating disinformation was therefore of great importance.
"The Evidence, The Witness, The Perpetrator"
Emre outlined the various initiatives undertaken by Anadolu Agency following the onset of Israel’s genocide in Gaza and provided information about the book series "Kanıt (The Evidence)", "Tanık (The Witness)", and “Sanık (The Perpetrator)".
Recalling that the series' book "Evidence" documents Israel's crimes through footage captured by AA reporters and cameramen and that this booklet was submitted to the International Criminal Court as evidence and was accepted, Emre said they had seen the importance of a single frame captured by a journalist in international courts.
Explaining that the "Perpetrator" book features those responsible for these crimes, while the "Witness" book features journalists who directly witnessed the events, Emre advised participants to examine these works.
Offering recommendations on how to combat disinformation, Emre said, "Never, under any circumstances, click 'retweet' on a news item you read if it has not been reported by reliable sources or by news agencies."
Emre underscored that social media should no longer be a platform where only food photos are shared or funny videos are retweeted; rather, it should be used for a purpose.
Emre said that dozens of videos on YouTube explain how Israel seeks to influence the subconscious, and that people need to learn how to combat artificial platforms and algorithms.